Call McGarr Solicitors on: 01 6351580

Home » Negligence » Page 7

Negligence

Saying… No!

Ireland is currently coming to the consideration of profound derelictions of duty of a number of people, including and particularly, leading politicians. The generalized defence coming out is that someone else was responsible. The law has long had to deal with that kind of response. A solicitor, for example, is not entitled to say that he/she is following the advice of Counsel; that advice must be assessed by the solicitor and not be blindly followed. Probably a nurse should not […]

More

OK, Boss. Boss?

Sometimes it is difficult for lawyers to recognize who is the boss.

More

You Know What I Mean…

Readers will have seen reference HERE to a plea in a medical negligence case as to the meaning of a “consent” signed by the patient (who was having an operation to make her sterile). In Fitzpatrick v National Maternity Hospital [2008] IEHC 62 the Defendant claimed that the mother (in labour) declined an episiotomy or a forceps-assisted birth (leading to the damage to the infant). The court rejected this plea, and rejected the evidence of the Defendant, intended to evidence […]

More

Limited Liability

Generally, the liability of a solicitor (arising out of his/her professional practise) is unlimited.

More

Accident: Frequency (The Law of Averages)

Road traffic accidents are common, but we rarely witness them happening. If we made a judgment of their frequency based on our experience, we would be wrong.

More

Accident; No witnesses (Requiescat in Pace)

a collision took place between a car and a lorry. It occurred on a straight stretch of road at night with no witnesses. The drivers and other occupants died. The available evidence was inconclusive as to fault. The court apportioned blame equally between the two drivers.

More

Accident: Settlement (Sign Here…)

The courts have frequently rejected arguments that claims have been settled, as purportedly evidenced by “releases” signed by Plaintiffs.

More

Accident: Pedestrian (Hello!)

The court, accepting a calculation that the car that hit her had been traveling at not more than 30 mph and was about 75 ft. from the crossing when the Plaintiff began to cross decided she had not been guilty of contributory negligence. She was 10 ft. onto the crossing when she was hit.

More

Car Accident (Gotcha?)

The Defendant driver admitted he did not see the Plaintiff pedestrian. The Plaintiff was an admirable witness, given that he was thrown into the air by the Defendant’s taxi. The Defendant gave evidence of the Plaintiff’s head hitting his windscreen. The judgment does not record the Plaintiff’s evidence in detail on the point, but if it was tendered it would probably have been in terms of the Defendant’s windscreen hitting him on the head.

More

Accident statistics (Wrong Number)

I imagine the reason for this is the tendency for failures to detect bone damage in x-rays to come to light by the pathetic return of the patient to the hospital with exacerbated injuries from neglect of the original injury.

More