Call McGarr Solicitors on: 01 6351580

Home » Blog » Freedom of Expression

EMI Records [Ireland] Ltd and Ors sue Irish ISPs

An interesting case has appeared in the High Court search system.

Yesterday, EMI Records [Ireland] Ltd, Sony Music Entertainment [Ireland] Ltd, Universal Music Ireland Ltd and Warner Music Ireland Ltd filed papers in the High Court central office to commence proceedings against UPC Communications Ireland Ltd, Vodafone Ireland Ltd, Imagine Telecommunications Ltd, Digiweb Ltd and Hutchinson 3 G Ltd.

The case is listed before the Commercial Court on the 17th December by way of Notice of Motion.

This, of course, will come to no surprise to anyone who followed the StopSOPAIreland campaign at the beginning of this year. The fact that the defendants do not include eircom (the only ISP to introduce the three strikes system the music label companies have demanded they are due by right, and the only ISP currently blocking the PirateBay after the music label companies made an undefended application to the High Court) is highly suggestive of the Plaintiff’s intent.

On the 5th December 2011 representatives of EMI and the other music companies met with Minister of State Sean Sherlock. They said they intended to seek the implementation of the SOPA-like Statutory Instrument so that they could seek injunctive relief against ISPs. You can read the memorandum of that meeting. They told the Minister “the wording of the SI as published is ideal” .

On the last day of February this year, the Government gave them their ideal law.

We may be seeing, on the 17th December of this year, the first of the predicted applications to block Ireland’s users from accessing particular websites.

If so- and the applicants are successful- it difficult to imagine that it will be the last.

2 Trackbacks

  1. By Irish ISPs facing legal action from record labels | on Friday, December 7, 2012 at 8:30 pm

    […] the SOPA Ireland campaign, solicitor Simon McGarr said this could be “the first of the predicted applications to block Ireland’s users from […]

  2. By SOPA 2012: A Year of Censorship in Review | SiliconANGLE on Friday, December 14, 2012 at 3:11 pm

    […] week, EMI, Sony Music Entertainment Ireland, Universal Music Ireland and Warner Music Ireland filed a case against a number of Ireland’s ISPs: UPC Communications Ireland, Vodafone Ireland, Imagine […]